Why
the Stone hammer Technology
The rural areas of developing countries face an
increasing demand for water, both for domestic
purposes and irrigation. However these countries
have often underground water reserves that could
be used in a sustainable way for irrigation.
Besides knowledge of irrigation skills, the
principal limiting factor is the high cost of
wells to gain access to the groundwater. Practica
recently identified a “new” well drilling
technology, the so-called Stone hammer, that has
the potential to substantially reduce the cost of
well drilling in hard ground layers. The
development of this technology started 3 years ago
in India and was successfully introduced in
Nicaragua in 2000.
Expected benefits
-
A method for manual well
drilling that can drill in harder ground layers and that is cheaper than
other manual drilling methods
-
A drilling technology
that can be produced and used with local materials and skills.
-
Increase food production
by irrigation (food security) by adding a
Low- cost option for manual well drilling.
-
Contribute to local
industry through the in-country manufacture of drilling equipment.
-
Increase the efficiency
and safety of manual well drilling for local well drillers.
The technology
Communal wells for drinking water
are often drilled with high-tech equipment, funded and organized by local
water departments and donor organizations like UNICEF, Care etc. However,
many wells are domestic wells, made and used by one or several families.
Traditionally these wells are made by “sludging” a small hole (tube well) of
8 to 15 cm diameter or digging a bigger hole by hand with a diameter of 1 to
1.5 meters.
Especially the construction of hand-dug wells deeper than 5 meter is a time
consuming, costly and often a dangerous activity..
To make low-cost tube wells, there are several hand drilling technologies
available around the world. For instance the sludging method in India or the
bailer and pulse technology as developed by DHV in Tanzania. Also there is
the rotative hand drilling technology as used in Zimbabwe or more recently
the EMAS method (using a mud pump) developed by GTZ in Bolivia. However all
these technologies have the limitation that they cannot drill through hard
layers like consolidated soil formations or ”tuff” stone. This presents a
serious limitation in countries like Nicaragua where some 80 % of the water
layers at 10 to 30 meter deep only can be reached if hard layers of 1 to 5
meter thick are passed.
New drilling technology
Recently a technology was
developed that has better potential to drill through harder soil formations
than the drilling technologies
mentioned before. This is the so called ”Stone hammer” a technology that was
developed in the North Bengal Terai Development project in India by Arcadis
Euroconsult.
The first experiences indicate that, compared to hand-dug wells, the Stone
Hammer has the following advantages:
-
Some 40 % cheaper ( $600
versus $1000 for a 20 meter well)
-
Better water quality
because of deeper penetration in the aquifer
-
Less accidents during
construction
-
Less risk of
contamination of the water
A drilled well is easier to cover so less risk of damage in
case of mud floods (like happened with the hurricane
“Mitch”)
The advantages of the Stone hammer
compared to machine-drilled wells are:
-
Cheaper because of input
of local labour. ($600 versus $1500)
-
Much simpler, less
maintenance problems (No “high-tech” parts like carburretor, gearbox etc.)
Compared to machine drilled wells a draw back of the Stone hammer is that
it is slower.
4.
Current status
After the “Indian Stone hammer”
was adapted in Nicaragua, a first set of drilling equipment was produced in
Nicaragua and 5 wells
were drilled in the pacific region. During these drillings several types of
ground layers with different “hardnesses” were encountered. For some layers,
the used technology proved to be successful, for instance a 10-meter deep
well was drilled in 2 days. In other ground layers the well drilling took
several weeks because drill bits were damaged. Another problem was that it
is very time consuming to dismantle the tubes every time the drill is
lifted. Therefore tubes and drill bits have to be adapted to improve quality
and reduce time.
Also adaptations are needed that combine the sludging method with the Stone
hammer technology. Extensive field test are needed to improve durability and
standardize the technology to make it suitable for local production and
further implementation.
Hand- sludge drilling in Nicaragua.